Old Agoura Homes
Agoura Hills, CA | $1.5M-$4.5M+
Old Agoura Homes
Don’t let the name fool you, not everything in Old Agoura is old, in fact many homes have been rebuilt just in this decade. The variety here is extensive. For the cowboys and cowgirls, we’re not only talking stunning estates, we’re talking large lots and barns for horses. Not so wild west? You’re still covered, Old Agoura has everything from ordinary houses to some that look like they were built 50 years ago.
Agoura Hills | The Overview
Curious what it’s like to live in Agoura Hills beyond this neighborhood? From hillside homes and equestrian pockets to schools, commute access, and how it compares to nearby towns, here’s the full local breakdown.
Old Agoura | Quick Take
A rural pocket of Agoura Hills where horse trails and custom homes replace tract streets.
- Lifestyle: Trail riding, a riding ring, and large lots give it a genuine country feel, with a mix of stunning custom estates and homes that look decades older than they are.
- Identity: One of the few truly rural neighborhoods this close to the rest of the Conejo Valley, drawing everyone from horse owners to families who just want more privacy.
- Trade-off: Horse country comes with horse country realities, some dust and the occasional barnyard smell, and many homes are still on septic systems with custom layouts that can feel a little unconventional.
- Bottom line: Best for buyers seeking privacy, acreage, or an equestrian lifestyle without leaving city limits behind entirely.
MICHAEL RICE, Conejo Valley Guy | Let's Connect!
Quick Facts at A Glance
Typical Price Range
$1.5M-$4.5M+
Home Size (SQ FT)
Custom
Number of Homes (Approx.)
300+
Bedrooms
2-6
Year Built
1930-today
What's To Love
Old Agoura breaks the mold that is most of The Conejo Valley. The country feel here is one of a kind in the area. Plus the trail riding and riding ring bring a little extra something to the many parks and hikes around.
What's Not To Love
You’re in horse country here, so if you don’t like that barnyard smell and some dust clouds, you may feel out of place. Custom homes can mean some odd layouts and many of the homes are still on septic tanks.
Who Should Look Here
Not just horse people if that’s what you were expecting. Many people gravitate to Old Agoura to get a sense of solitude while still being close to civilization. And if the tract style look that’s prevalent through much of Agoura Hills isn’t your style, you’ll appreciate the architecture of Old Agoura. Your typical neighbor is a mix of everything – from cowpokes and farmhands, to couples and families.
Hi, I’m Michael
These neighborhood profiles are designed to go beyond what you’ll find on Zillow or Redfin. After 25+ years working in the Conejo Valley and profiling more than 165 neighborhoods, I’ve learned that the small differences between communities often matter the most.
Homes for Sale in Old Agoura
Old Agoura Market Snapshot
This snapshot shows recent sales activity in Old Agoura to give a general sense of how the neighborhood has been performing over time.
| 2023 | 2024 | 2025 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Average Sale Price: | $1,973,954 | $2,869,944 | $2,692,698 |
| Lowest Price: | $1,025,000 | $1,130,000 | $1,101,000 |
| Highest Price: | $3,450,000 | $6,400,000 | $4,300,000 |
| Number of Sales: | 11 | 17 | 22 |
| Avg. Days on Market: | 104 | 83 | 88 |
Buying a home in Old Agoura?
If you’re starting to think about what it would actually look like to buy in Old Agoura, this is a good place to start.
I’ll walk you through what to expect, how the process works, and the key decisions you’ll want to think through before making an offer.
Before You BuySelling a home in Old Agoura?
If you own a home in Old Agoura and are thinking about selling, it helps to understand what typically goes into the costs and what you might realistically walk away with.
I break it down clearly so you can make a more informed decision.
Estimate Your Net ProceedsOld Agoura Location
Exploring Your Agoura Hills Options
Old Agoura is one of several distinct neighborhoods within Agoura Hills. If you’re still getting your bearings, these guides can help.
Compare Neighborhoods
OLD AGOURA FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Most buyers assume “Old Agoura” means every home is old, but that’s far from the case. You’ll find everything from original ranch homes to recently built custom estates, often on the same street. The name describes the neighborhood’s history, not necessarily the age of the homes.
Prices typically run $1.5M-$4.5M+. Custom estates on larger parcels with equestrian facilities command the highest prices, while smaller homes or properties needing updates provide a more accessible way into one of the area’s most unique neighborhoods.
Old Agoura feels more like rural Southern California than suburban Agoura Hills. Horse trails, large lots, mature trees, and custom homes create a setting that’s completely different from the tract neighborhoods found throughout much of the Conejo Valley.
Old Agoura appeals to buyers looking for privacy, acreage, and a rural lifestyle. Westlake Trails and Morrison Highlands offer a more traditional suburban experience with greater architectural consistency and smaller lots.
While equestrian buyers are certainly drawn to Old Agoura, many homeowners simply want more land, privacy, and a neighborhood that doesn’t feel like a typical subdivision. It’s a good fit for buyers who value space and character over uniformity.
Many homes also rely on septic systems, so inspections are especially important. Living in horse country comes with tradeoffs like dust, wildlife, and occasional odors, but for many buyers that’s a small price to pay for the privacy and open space.
Ready to tour Old Agoura and other neighborhoods?
Choosing the right neighborhood is often more important than choosing the right house. If you’re still figuring out where you belong in the Conejo Valley, here’s the simple 3-step process I use to help buyers narrow it down.
Step 1:
First Meeting
We’ll talk through your plans and what buying looks like in the Conejo Valley.
Step 2:
Area & Home Tours
You’ll get a feel for how the towns connect and which ones feel right to you.
Step 3:
Offers → Closing
I’ll guide you through offers, negotiations, and all the way to closing.
